Cast List
| Role | Week 1 Cast (A) 12/5-12/7 |
Week 2 Cast (B) 12/12-12/14 |
|---|---|---|
| Grace | Grace Stine | Shaeleigh Hreskowsky |
| Nikki | Charlotte Powell | Madelyn Schnelle |
| Schmederick | Walter Samuels | Cameron Tyo |
| Charlotte/Charlotta | Shelby Ward | Sarah Sieferman |
| Santa & Mrs. Claus | Kurt & Carol Homann | Josh & Amber Howard |
| Queen of the Northern Sky | Olivia Simmons | Milly Stine |
| Karaoke | Kailyn Howard | Bradleigh Nelson |
| Fun Oven Supreme | Kat Cherry | Ingrid Sieferman |
| Barbara | Audrey Norman | Lily Baldwin |
| Trivia | Declan Simmons | Max Short |
| Game Dude | Isaac Simmons | Oliver Cook |
| Taxi Cab | Cole Arthur | Micaiah Frey |
| Mobile | Abygail Dowden | Ainsley Kight |
| Elf 1 | Myla Samuels | Evy Morgan |
| Elf 2 | Rebecca Cherry | Kay Goins |
| Icicle Giant | Eli Brown | Nathan Woosley Camden Crowder |
| Grace’s Dad | Josh Howard | Landon Birge |
| Grace’s Mom | Amber Howard | Arianna Osterhoudt |
| Young Grace | Audrey Simmons | Frances Cotten |
| Parent (store) | Ellen Simpson | Heather Morgan |
| Child 1 (store) | Liam Howard | Westyn Cornelius |
| Child 2 (store) | Piper Swinford | Poppy Grider |
| Ensemble (toys, kids) | Emma Pack Andrew Gardner Audrey Simmons |
Lilia Frey Campbell Stine Frances Cotten |
| Customers (store) | Abygail Dowden Josh Howard Amber Howard Myla Samuels Rebecca Cherry Eli Brown |
Ainsley Kight Landon Birge Arianna Osterhoudt Evy Morgan Kay Goins Nathan Woosley Camden Crowder Caden Tyo |
